TL;DR
Comparison
Should we use resident arbitration agreements?
Whose decision: Operators of certified facilities and licensed assisted living, and anyone reviewing an admission packet.
Last updated
| Factor | Binding arbitration | A jury trial |
|---|---|---|
| Effect on the severity tail | Removes it; no jury, no runaway outcome | Fully exposed to it |
| Effect on average claim value | Modest; arbitrators award compensatory damages too | Baseline |
| Cost and duration | Usually faster and cheaper, though arbitrator fees are real | Longer, and defense spend accumulates on an eroding limit |
| Punitive exposure | Generally reduced, subject to the agreement and applicable law | Available where the statute or the conduct supports it |
| Confidentiality | Usually private, which matters where the record is itself a liability | Public, and the record follows you into the next case |
| Enforceability risk | Substantial, and it turns on formation rather than on arbitration | None; this is the default |
| Wrongful death claims | In several states an agreement signed by the resident does not bind an independent wrongful death claimant | Applies to all claimants |
| Underwriting credit | Available where the execution practice will survive challenge | None |
The recommendation
The agreement itself is close to worthless. What has value is an execution practice that survives challenge, and the failures are always the same: presented in a stack of admission paperwork during a crisis, signed by a family member whose power of attorney did not cover the decision, made a condition of admission where that is prohibited, or signed by a resident whose capacity nobody assessed on the day.
The practice that earns underwriting credit is a separate document, separately signed, presented after admission or with a documented right to rescind within a stated window, explained in a documented conversation, signed by the resident where capacity exists with a contemporaneous capacity note, signed by an agent only where the power of attorney on file grants that authority, with a copy provided and a receipt acknowledged, and a tracked rescission rate. An agreement nobody ever rescinds is evidence that nobody understood it was optional.
Then ask your defense counsel one question before relying on the program: does an agreement signed by the resident bind a wrongful death claimant in this state. Where the answer is no, arbitration still reduces frequency cost and does not reduce the severity tail, and you should not expect underwriting to price it as though it did. That is not a reason to abandon the program. It is a reason to keep the limit sized as though the highest-value claims will be tried.
Follow-up questions
Not in facilities participating in Medicare and Medicaid. Federal requirements prohibit requiring an agreement as a condition of admission and impose explanation and copy obligations. State law adds requirements in some jurisdictions, and an agreement that violates either is the version most likely to be struck.
Rarely a stated percentage. It shows up as a willingness to quote, a lower retention, or a rate at the better end of the range. Ask your broker to characterize how the arbitration program affected the quote rather than expecting a discount line on the proposal.
Usually, and that matters more in senior care than in most classes, because a public verdict or a public settlement becomes discovery material in the next case and marketing material for the firm that brought it. Confidentiality is a genuine part of the value and it is worth confirming the agreement provides for it.
Go deeper
Other comparisons
Should I pay more for defense outside the limit?
Which trigger should a senior care liability program be written on?
Should I insist on an admitted carrier?
Should we put our program in a risk retention group?
Is a captive the right structure for us, or should we stay on a guaranteed cost program?
Is a per location aggregate worth the extra premium?
Free coverage review
Send the declarations page and a specialist returns an item-by-item read within one business day.